“…you have an all-out prize fight, you wait until the fight is over, one guy is left standing. And that's how you know who won.”
-- Al Capone in "The Untouchables"
-- Al Capone in "The Untouchables"
In the 2008 NHL Entry Draft, nine goalies were selected ahead of Braden Holtby, who was picked 93rd overall by the Washington Capitals. At the time, there were no fewer than five goalies were ahead of Holtby on the Capitals’ depth chart – Jose Theodore, Brent Johnson, Semyon Varlamov, Michal Neuvirth, and Daren Machesney.
Five years later, Theodore, Johnson, Varlamov, and Machesney have moved on, and Holtby is at the top of the heap, having come out on top in his mano-a-mano competition with Michal Neuvirth over the past two seasons. In 2013 Holtby was the number one goalie from start to finish for the first time in his third season with the big club. Not that it came with a sense of certainty attached to it. In parts of the previous two seasons Holtby appeared in only 21 regular season games. Despite some sparkling numbers – 14-4-3, 2.02, .929, with three shutouts in those 21 appearances – it took his post-season performance in 2012 (1.95 GAA/.935 save percentage in 14 games) to lift him into the lead in the goalie competition going into 2013.
The Great Lockout of 2012-2013 left Holtby plying his trade in Hershey with the AHL Bears, where he had an iffy 12-12-1 record, but with a 2.14 goals against average and a .932 save percentage. Both the GAA and save percentage would have ranked him fourth in the AHL had he qualified in the end-of-season rankings.
When the NHL season got underway in January, the jump to stiffer competition did not agree with Holtby. He appeared in the Caps’ first two games but allowed ten goals on 73 shots (.863 save percentage). It earned him a seat for five games and put his position as number one goalie in jeopardy. Michal Neuvrith had struggles of his own, not reaching the .900 level in save percentage in any of those five games. Holtby returned in Game 8 of the season but continued to struggle into his second ten-game segment of the season.
However, starting with a 38-save effort in a 2-1 loss to the New York Rangers on February 17th, Holtby’s season began to turn around. His ten-game splits improved significantly over his first ten-game split. Over his last four splits he did not record a save percentage lower than .916, and he dropped his goals against average from 4.52 in his first ten-game split to 2.58 by season’s end. In those last four splits Holtby was 22-9-1, 2.34, .927 with four shutouts. Holtby was clearly the number one goalie in Washington.
Odd Holtby Statistic… Braden Holtby was 1-4-1, 4.37, .864 against teams from Pennsylvania, the Penguins and Flyers. He was 22-8-0, 2.28, .929 with four shutouts against everyone else.
Game to Remember… March 21/22 at Winnipeg. When the Caps headed to Winnipeg for a back-to-back set of games in Manitoba – a scheduling quirk as a result of the lockout – they had just come off one of their best games of the season but had nothing to show for it. They fought the Pittsburgh Penguins to a draw over 50 minutes, holding the mighty Penguins to a single goal. Then, just after a Caps power play expired, Matt Niskanen took a feed from Matt Cooke and wristed a puck that just cleared a sliding Karl Alzner and eluded Braden Holtby’s glove for the game-winner in 2-1 loss. The Caps were still buried in the standings, 14th in the East and nine points behind the Winnipeg Jets, who they would visit for this back-to-back.
Getting swept in Winnipeg probably would have ended the competitive portion of the season for the Caps, since they would have been 13 points behind the Jets with 27 games to play. But that was not what happened. The Caps swept the Jets, due in large part to Holtby holding the home team to one goal on 51 shots over the two games, the lone Jets goal coming in the third period after the Caps had built a 5-1 lead in Game 2 of the set. His shutout in Game 1 of the set was his second straight over the Jets in 2013.
Game to Forget… February 3rd vs. Pittsburgh. If the March 19th game against the Penguins was one of the best the Caps played to that point in the 2013 season, it was due in part to the game against the Penguins on February 3rd being among the worst. Holtby was particulary tormented by Chris Kunitz. First it was a tip in off a point shot less than four minutes into the game. Then it was a snap shot from the top of the left wing circle to give the Penguins a 4-2 lead. Six minutes later, with the Pens on a power play and Karl Alzner without a stick – making it effectively a 5-on-3 – it was one-timer from the bottom of the left wing circle. Finally, it was a one-timer from the slot that beat Holtby on the last shot he faced on the day for Kunitz’ fourth goal of the game. Holtby allowed six goals on 26 shots in the 6-3 loss.
Post Season… It would have been hard for Braden Holtby to improve on his numbers from the 2012 playoffs (1.95, .935). Only five times in 14 games in 2012 did he allow more than two goals. He was not far off, though, in 2013 (2.22, .922). Here is the thing, though. Until Game 7 he was better than last season, a 1.77 goals against average and a .938 save percentage. Then there was Game 7. It was a classic case of a team – the Caps – dominating the game early, but unable to capitalize on Holtby’s opposite number, Henrik Lundqvist. When the momentum changed, the Rangers capitalized – often. New York scored five goals over a span of 33:20 from 13:19 of the first period (on a goal from an unlikely source: Arron Asham) to 6:39 of the third (again from an unlikely source: Mats Zuccarello). Holtby and the Caps picked the wrong time to suffer a team-wide collapse.
In the end…
Let’s compare a couple of goaltenders and their first three regular season in the league:
Goalie A: 57 games, 37-16-4, 2.39, .923, 7 shutouts
Goalie B: 59 games, 30-13-12, 2.39, .917, 4 shutouts
Not much separating them, is there? Now, let’s look at the same two goalies in the post season over those three years:
Goalie A: 21 games, 10-11, 2.04, .931, 1 shutout
Goalie B: 19 games, 10-9, 2.49, .915, 2 shutouts
Goalie A has better numbers overall (not that the win-loss record reflects it) and is more consistent (Goalie B has those two shutouts in 19 games, but almost a half-goal higher GAA). Who are they?
Goalie A is Braden Holtby, Goalie B is Semyon Varlamov in his first three seasons in the league, all with Washington. Varlamov was sent to Colorado after that third season, in no small part due to stories that if he was not the Caps’ number one goalie, he would consider going to Europe to play. Holtby, on the other hand, is something of the “last man standing,” having climbed up the depth chart until he stands now as the Caps’ number one goalie. At the moment, there is no question who won.
Photo: Bruce Bennett/Getty Images North America