Theme: “There comes a time when all the cosmic tumblers have clicked into place, and the universe opens itself for a few seconds, to show you what is possible….”
-- Terence Mann (in “Field of Dreams”)
Going into the 2012-2013 season, Troy Brouwer was building a reputation for being a hard-nosed forward who could chip in the occasional or timely goal from the second or third line. It might have been the “hard-nosed” part that had particular appeal to the Caps when Washington traded the 26th overall pick in the 2011 entry draft for Brouwer in June 2011. In his first year with the Caps, Brouwer finished seventh in the league among forwards in hits. It was the third straight season in which he finished in the top 15 in that statistic, following a rookie season in which he finished fourth among rookies in hits.
Then came the 2012-2013 season. New season, new coach, new Brouwer. The Caps finished only 18th in the league in hits (they finished 10th in 2011-2012). Part of the drop in the league rankings was Brouwer’s drop from seventh in 2011-2012 to a tie for 29th in 2012-2013. On the other side – the occasional and timely goal side – Brouwer had what amounted to a career year, given the abbreviated nature of the schedule. In 47 games played in the 48-game season, Brouwer finished with 19 goals, surpassed only by his 22 goals in 78 games in the 2009-2010 season. Of those 19 goals last season, seven came on the power play, and five were game-winners (only one of the five game-winners came on a power play).
His goal-scoring, coming as it did from the second line and the first unit on the power play, provided some of the depth of scoring that the Caps have lacked from time to time and took some of the man-advantage scoring burden off of Alex Ovechkin.
I used that quote above in the 2012-2013 preview for Brouwer. It was used in another context. This time around it fits for those “few seconds.”
The “few seconds” in cosmological time might correspond to an NHL season. An abbreviated one, mind you, but one in which Troy Brouwer would score goals (33) at almost twice his career per-82 game rate going into the season (17). And, although Brouwer was very efficient as a shooter (17.1 percent shooting percentage), it was not a career year for him in that regard. He shot to a 19.0 percent rate in 2009-2010, when he had 22 goals in 78 games in the Chicago Blackhawks’ run to the Stanley Cup.
What contributed to Brouwer’s unexpectedly prolific year was his performance on the power play. His seven power play goals tied a career high, but it worked out to a per-82 game rate of 12 power play goals. Not that his even-strength production was weak. His 12 even-strength goals was not a career high (he had 15 for the Caps in 2011-2012), but with 11 in 47 games he was on a 19 goal pace per 82 games.
Let’s go back to that power play performance. Brouwer was a whole lot more efficient in 2012-2013 than he was in 2011-2012. In 2011-2012 he had three goals on 25 5-on-4 power play shots (12.0 percent) in 170:37 of ice time. Last season he had seven power play goals on 28 shots (25.0 percent) in 147:09 of ice time. Was this an “Adam Oates” effect by inserting him in the middle of the Caps’ 1-3-1 power play structure, or merely a case of “a few seconds” showing what was possible?
At even strength Brouwer is likely to have to suit up next to yet another center. Think back to his first shift with the Caps in 2011. Who was his center? Mathieu Perreault. He’s been lined up alongside Marcus Johansson, Matt Hendricks, and Brooks Laich. He’s been lined up alongside Keith Aucoin. He’s been lined up alongside Mike Ribeiro. Now, it looks as if he will be lined up with Mikhail Grabovski. Is this going to work?
The Big Question… Was last season a sustainable new normal or merely a blip in the career statistics for Troy Brouwer?
On the one hand, Caps fans might like to look at Troy Brouwer and his 19 goals 47 games of the 2013 season (a 33-goal pace over 82 games) and see a “Mike Knuble,” who did not reach 20 goals for a full season until he was 30 years old, then ran off eight straight 20-plus goal seasons (averaging 27 a year). Brouwer just turned 28 years old. In this scenario he might be about to embark on the prime scoring years of his career, which would be great news for Caps fans who would like to see a bigger threat coming out of that second line.
On the other hand, if you head over to hockey-reference.com you will see that his primary comparables in production over the first seven years of his career are Shawn Burr and Paul Ranheim. If they really are comparables, Caps fans might not be as happy. Burr had his career season (24-32-56) at age 23 with the Detroit Red Wings (that was in 1989-1990, before the Red Wings got good). Ranheim had his best years, goal-scoring wise, at 26 and 27 years old when he recorded a total of 44 goals over the 1991-1992 and 1992-1993 seasons with the Calgary Flames. He never had more than ten goals in any season after that.
In the end…
Troy Brouwer’s effectiveness as a power play scorer had consequences last season. The Caps were 6-1-0 in games in which Brouwer scored a power play goal, but only 14-8-2 in games in which the Caps scored a power play goal without Brouwer getting one. And, when you consider that the Caps were 7-9-1 in games in which they failed to score a power play goal, the matter of Brouwer’s ability to produce on the power play takes on importance for the 2013-2014 season.
Of greater import, though, is how he will mesh with another new center. Mikhail Grabovski is not the playmaker Mike Ribeiro was, and this could have consequences for Brouwer’s even strength production. If Grabovski scores more on his own than Ribeiro, this is not likely to be a problem. Still, the nature of Brouwer’s production in the 2013 season makes him one of the bigger question marks of the coming season, leaving Caps fans to ponder if it was his career year or the harbinger of a step up on his career path.
Projection: 80 games, 22-19-41, plus-3
Photo: Greg Fiume/Getty Images North America